Room 101 Jewelry

Chaos As Social Order

Introduction

            Chaos is a new way of understanding social order.  Rather than a perverse paradox, this assertion draws on the diverse developments of chaos theory in the natural and mathematical sciences (Barnsley 1988; Crutchfield et al 1986; Dewdney 1985; Gleick 1987; Mandelbrot 1983; Mullin 1993).  Over the past two decades, chaos theory has been applied in many disciplines of theoretical and applied science (Baier and Klein 1991; Cohen and Stewart 1994; Davies and Gribbin 1992; Gleick 1987; Hao 1990; Holden 1986; Moon 1987; Mullin 1993; Rasband 1990; Ruelle 1989), including some areas of social science (Brown 1994; Chen; Dendrinos and Sonis 1990; Gell-Mann 47-48; Goodwin 1990; Hao 573-632; Holton and May; Kiel and Elliott 1996; Lewin 44-62; Nicolis 1991).  The latter applications, however, have used chaos theory as a mathematical tool incorporated into conventional conceptual frameworks rather than as an alternative conceptual framework which could illuminate the very social order from which chaos theory has arisen.  To serve conceptually chaos theory must be understood conceptually.

            In this article, I do not produce mathematical models or computer simulations nor do I offer copious new data.  I also definitely do not use chaos as a metaphor.  This is not a literary exercise designed to decorate the social sciences with yet another image, such as the machine, the organism, the deductive system, or the adversarial debate (Morgan 1986).

            It might seem appropriate to group chaos with such heuristic metaphors.  These metaphors have been used in social science to approach and explore phenomena which were thought to be otherwise intractable to rigorous scientific examination.  However, the success of multiple research efforts in the mathematical, physical, life, and social sciences in identifying various kinds of chaotic dynamics suggests that chaos should be grouped not with metaphors but with known types of order such as linear deterministic, stochastic, and random.

            This grouping emphasizes that I use chaos as a theory not as a model (Harvey and Reed 309).  My use of chaos is therefore theoretic and not semantic (Richards 98).  This grouping also does not deny that the bulk of existing research has regarded chaos as an outcome of changes in parameters of deterministic systems.  Chaos is usually viewed as deterministic chaos.  It affirms, additionally, the discovery of chaotic dynamics in social science data (Kiel and Elliot) where the social situations generating the data cannot be reduced to linear deterministic principles or equations.  From this affirmation seems to flow the possibility that chaos is a kind of order which is not strictly dependent on deterministic systems for its existence.  Indeed, as a type of order, chaos may be the first clear, non-reductionist link between certain specific conditions in numeric and physical systems, such as phase transitions, and a pervasive, spontaneous quality of social reality.  Rather than a fad or a misplaced metaphor, chaos may be a small window into a new and larger way of understanding human life which includes determinism, stochasticity, and randomness.

            Grouping chaos with known types of order frames chaos as a comprehensible form of order rather than as a metaphor for some incomprehensible condition.  Besides being a more useful alignment, this grouping also raises a deeper question for the philosophy or foundations of social science.  This question defines the horizon of my inquiry here:  What properties must the (social) universe have in order to exhibit all four kinds of order?

            Considering chaos as a type of order allows me to use the results of experiments to prepare the conceptual ground for chaos as social order.  I present the established features of chaos which bear on social order.  I highlight the mixing/folding phenomenon characteristic of physical chaotic phenomena (Crutchfield et al 51-4; Gleick 122, 255, 257; Mullin 19-21).  My focus on social power as actions upon actions provides a necessary bridge for understanding chaos as social order.

            After this presentation of chaos theory as a conceptual framework, I then lay out an application of chaos theory to diverse social phenomena–oppression, modernization, language change, moral change, political change, and cyberspace.  In the course of this application, I show that chaos theory can be used conceptually to clarify contemporary social order but that the nature of social phenomena place significant limitations on the mathematical application of chaos theory to social science data.

Social Power

            We begin by reflecting on the fact that others–mother, father, siblings, pets, blankets, rain, sun–have been acting upon us for a long time.  Others, both animate and inanimate, have been acting not only on our bodies as rain acts on tin, water, or sand but more specifically on our bodies’ attempts to act.  These actions include the entire range of qualities–caress and punch, embrace and push, praise and blame, approve and reject, and so on.  These actions upon our actions have induced and introduced social power:  actions upon actions.

            Actions upon actions sounds repetitive.  Not redundant, but repetitive in the sense that something similar is recurring in each action.  Similarity through difference characterizes individual life stories, family histories, and community histories.  Indeed, as historical beings, all of human life is involved in each human action upon an action–patterned, compressed, focused, refracted, fractionated–as much as all of a language is “in” any instance of its use.

            What precisely then is the process of actions upon actions?  We can interpret the phrase as scalar recursion which is the recurrence of similar structure on different scales.  Something is similar in every instance of actions upon actions, whether it is in the relationships between a Supreme Commander and an entire military establishment, a lieutenant and a platoon, or one private and another.

            Paying closer attention to the phrase “actions upon actions” supports such a linking of social power with chaos theory.  The first and third terms–”actions”–are identical but this identity is qualified by the second term–”upon.”  The preposition “upon” is used rather than those which indicate symmetry or equality, such as “with,” “together with,” “beside,” etc.  The verbal sense of “action” is amplified by the dynamic sense of the preposition.  These observations may be provisionally summarized:  the structure of social power as actions upon actions is dynamic asymmetry.

            We next observe the absence of any modifiers of the noun “actions.”  Words such as “all,” “most,” “many,” “some,” etc. could have been used.  But no one can actually count the number of actions upon their body.  This noncountability extends across all human time scales.  This is true whether the time scale of the actions is generations of national patterns mediated by living cohorts, years of family patterns mediated by relatives, years of being a consumer, student, parent, child, or employee, or months of dating, going steady, being engaged, or being married.  It is not possible, therefore, to fit this idea of social power into a quantitative, countability dualism such as finite/infinite.  This impossibility in turn refines the provisional summary in the preceding paragraph:  “upon” is ambivalently or ambiguously asymmetric.  It is not necessarily either symmetric or asymmetric.

From Detector To Attractor

            This understanding of social power can be used as a power detector.  It can be used in any human situation to bring into view, to outline or highlight, to unmask or reveal, power relations.  This power detector is not like a metal detector that finds a distinct, physical thing nor is it like a thermometer that quantitatively reduces a complex physical condition.  It is a detector of human situations in which people’s actions may be found to be acting upon people’s actions.  It can be used analytically to consider relations of cooperation or collaboration, which are indeed actions upon actions, as well as to consider situations of oppression.  It predicts that social power will be dynamic, ambiguously and fluidly symmetric/asymmetric, and numerically uncountable.

            The condition of uncountability may be understood as meaning that actions can be decomposed and recomposed indefinitely into more and less inclusive patterns.  The oppression of being forcibly confined in a mental institution, for example, can be analyzed in many terms–architectural, political, economic, familial, social, psychiatric, etc.  All the terms are relevant to an analysis aimed at completeness though none of the terms exhausts the entire range of actions upon actions in such a situation.

            We can now consider a smooth social process or the surface of water in laminar flow without turbulence or chaos.  The onset of turbulence or chaos constitutes both a qualitative and a quantitative change from the laminar condition and is not simply an accumulation of prior conditions.  The change introduces a pattern characterized by repetition and similarity across different scales of the pattern.  The detector of social power detects a repeated action upon action among human beings.  The repetition and the similarity indicate a certain attraction of the actors to one another.  The detector indicates an attractor.

            In chaos theory, an attractor is a pattern in space.  The kind of space is state or phase space.  Phase space is a multidimensional space inclusive of the Cartesian coordinates and the momentum of a system, i.e., the attractor.  There are many definitions of attractors in the literature (Cohen and Stewart 204-7; Coveney and Highfield 166-75; Gleick 150, 232-6; Hao 16-18, 51-63; Kiel and Elliott 26, 54-5, 172; Mainzer 4-7, 58-9; Mullin x-xii; etc.).  Moon’s definition is simple and useful:  An attractor is a “set of points or a subspace in phase space toward which a time history approaches after transients die out.  For example, equilibrium points or fixed points in maps, limit cycles, or a toroidal surface for quasiperiodic motions, are all classical dynamical attractors” (261).  The attractor pattern is an equilibrium state or set of states to which a dynamical system converges.  An attractor is not necessarily either one or many states exclusively.

            The verbal phrase “to which…converges” conveys this non-dualistic quality and also points toward the quality of an attractor that makes it strange:  a final equilibrium is never reached–symmetry is never reached, nor is a “stable” asymmetry reached.  The pattern shows self-similarity across scales but it never reaches an identity, or, equilibrium condition.  Using Moon again, a strange attractor is “the attracting set in phase space on which chaotic orbits move.  An attractor that is not an equilibrium point nor a limit cycle, nor a quasiperiodic attractor.  An attractor in phase space with fractal dimension” (267).

            A strongly defining characteristic of a strange attractor, moreover, is sensitive dependence on initial conditions.  The pattern of a strange attractor may be taken as the pathways of points that begin at arbitrarily small distances from each other.  Over time, those distances change so much and so quickly that at a later time in the pattern the initial conditions are no longer observable.  The later state of the pattern or system cannot therefore be connected deterministically with the beginning state.

            It has been proven repeatedly in both numerical and physical experiments that such a pattern must involve simultaneous folding and stretching.  For example, you put a spot of dark blue dye on the surface of a large lump of white bread dough.  You then knead the dough.  Kneading folds and stretches the dough.  Folding and stretching mixes the blue dye through the dough until it is distributed throughout the dough.  The entire mass of dough is pale blue.  It is physically or mathematically impossible to determine from the final state of mixed dye where in the dough the spot was in the beginning.  The sensitivity of the system to its initial conditions thus means that, regardless of how close to each other the elements are initially, stretching and folding results in the initial conditions no longer being observable or deterministically relevant.  Such mixing involves simultaneous expansion and contraction.  As this happens, old or earlier information is destroyed and new or later information is created.

Chaos And Oppression

            When introduced into a consideration of oppression, this approach illuminates some crucial aspects.  First, oppression works on the human body in two distinct ways–one by removing the body from home and two by covering the body with non-indigenous, uniform clothes.  Examples of both operations can be found with prisoners of war, convicted criminals, committed mental patients, military personnel, and students in compulsory education.

            Second, oppression works on human structures and on the earth.  Imperialism, whether religious, political, military, or ecological, has repeatedly involved the destruction of buildings and of parts of the earth such as groves, crops, livestock, fields, and species.  Examples are the destruction of groves of trees in the Old Testament, the burning of manuscripts in China in 212 BC and the burning of the library in Alexandria, in 525 AD.  More currently, the destruction of human living spaces and places, from rain forests, to living sites, to old sections of cities, involves the destruction of old information and the creation of new information.

            Combining these two operations of oppression, we see the human bodies of survivors, born and bred close together, then moved, mixed, and clothed so that, when observed later, no traces of their initial conditions–their indigenous or native states–remain.  The old information about the former identity of the displaced persons or of the destroyed places is replaced by new information resulting from actions upon the persons and the places.  If we add to this the repression, disuse and disappearance of unprivileged languages and customs, then the image of uniform mixing, or, mixing for uniformity, becomes clearer.

            Third, sensitive dependence on initial conditions in both numerical and physical experiments involves amplification of small initial differences into larger differences later.  Twins, siblings, and neighborhood or village cohorts often develop lifeways that not only put out of focus their initial conditions but also differ from one another in ways that are not susceptible to deterministic, linear calculation.  In the case of groups of ethnically homogeneous refugees crossing a border into another country, individual lifeways can diverge beyond linear reckoning over time.

            From the standpoint of social power, the actions of such people are worked on by the actions of social operations that “mix,” “fold,” and “stretch” everyone.  At one and the same time, contemporary, industrial, urban society functions to stereotype everyone while making available the physical and mental means for individual differentiation.  From the standpoint of chaos theory, this allows for indefinitely small and large distances between points, or subjects, in the pattern of the strange attractor.  It also allows for signs and signals, such as hair styles, clothing, gestures and jewelry, web pages, and c(i)ber(dentities), increasingly bereft of any anchorings in known, traditional societies–traditional initial human conditions.  Instead, these signs and signals increasingly occur in production, consumption and communication patterns that transcend national, linguistic, and ethnic differences or origins.

            Such uniformity of pattern and signal leads, fourthly, to another illuminating characteristic of strange attractors also repeatedly proven by physical experiments.  This is a continuous power spectrum.  When a mutable medium, a fluid for example, is excited beyond a certain threshold, its measurable signals change sharply from continuous to discontinuous to continuous.  At the extreme level of excitation, the signals are continuous.  Rather than showing discrete peaks and valleys throughout the signal, the bulk of the signal is continuous, undifferentiated “noise” (Brown 135; McBurnett (2) 43-5).  Urban areas where waking human activities go on twenty-four hours a day are examples of such social “white noise.”  This noise has the power to eclipse bird-songs, wind sounds, and much of human speech.  In urban areas, everyone’s and everything’s sounds and noises are folded upon one another and mixed into collective sound.  This mixing produces a variety of aural experiences which cannot be predicted from knowing the origin and quality of any particular sound–emergence and synergy–and which blur into white noise in which no one sound dominates although any one sound may be momentarily more or less distinct.  In fact, the blur of urban noise obscures not only origins but also dynamics (Brown 123; Dendrinos 241; McBurnett (1)171-5, 185, 190).  Is the dynamics of urban “white noise” random, stochastic, chaotic or yet another type of order which a conceptual use of chaos theory can illuminate better than other kinds of order concepts?  I will return to this question in my conclusion.

            A continuous power spectrum connects with sensitive dependence on initial conditions in describing, at the onset of chaos, the destruction of old information and the creation of new information.  Pre-chaotic signals literally disappear and are replaced by erratically punctuated broadband noise.  This characteristic connects with oppression in that the latter always involves the injection of new energy into an existing system.  Destroying living sites, destroying some bodies and moving others, burying the dead and clothing the living then resocializing the survivors injects new energy into the bodies and into their relations with others.

            Oppression not only subjects bodies to new forms of energy but also makes new energy available to those bodies.  It should be emphasized here that this use of chaos theory does not lead to any simple, reductionist view of social power or of social order.  Social power may constrain or it may liberate or it may do both in the same situation and through the same person.  Declines in the hegemony of white, American, heterosexual, Christian males, books and chainsaws coupled with empowerment of women, children, homosexuals, non-whites, non-Christians, non-Euroamericans, hard drives, and endangered species show oscillations of social power in contemporary social order.

            Some further examples of this mixing and folding are Gandhi learning English and English law which he used to drive the British from India, Crazy Horse learning to use a rifle with which he killed invading soldiers, prisoners using weapons taken from guards against guards in prison riots, and students using computers to attack the military-industrial complex, university regulations, or high school dress codes.  This variable characteristic of energy-induced continuous power spectra–as though the law of the conservation of energy were functioning socially to preserve social power regardless of who has it or what its change of hands does to existing social order–shows that some kinds of social power persist through interruption.

            Two examples of persistent social power are the physical structure of a modern prison and the legal and temporal structure of modern mass education.  In the former, a prisoner’s body is disciplined twenty-four hours a day by its environment of bars, walls, locked doors, and fences with or without other individual human presence.  In the latter, people from six to sixteen years of age are persistently disciplined by a system that linearly encloses every day of the calendar year with its own significant events, such as the beginnings and endings of classes, quarters, terms, and semesters.

            A closer look at an excited fluid will strengthen the connections just mentioned.  When heat is applied to water in an open container the water moves gradually until there is a sharp transition to boiling.  Boiling may be understood as the creation of infinite surface in finite volume.  The water occupies a finite space.  The elements of the water, the water molecules, remain forever separate but move more and more rapidly.  Since the molecules cannot turn into each other and since they cannot stop moving, they must have infinite surface.  They get infinite surface by the rolling of the water which is a process of stretching and folding the fluid medium.

            The water mixes, folds and stretches indefinitely and unpredictably.  Boiling may be further understood as releasing thermal energy to air.  The more heated water is exposed on the surface to air, the more heat is released.  If the heat is stopped the water will cease boiling and return to its pre-chaotic, quiescent regime.  If the heat is continued the water will slowly vaporize until the container is empty.

            There are two phases of this event in which old, earlier information is destroyed and new, later information is created.  The first is the transition from quiescence to boiling.  The second is the transition from boiling to vapor.  All information about quiescent positions of water molecules disappears in boiling.  All information about boiling positions of water molecules disappears in vaporization.  It is impossible to ascertain by observing atmospheric water molecules when and where those molecules were parts of a fluid body of water, either boiling or quiescent.

            Many individuals and groups of individuals may be seen as culturally vaporized.  It is impossible from observing people on city streets to ascertain when or where those people, or their ancestors, were members of groups that could have been considered ethnically homogenous tribes, clans, or cultures.  As the borders of the world’s nations change, as data transfer technologies dissolve the barriers of time, space, and place, as war and environmental degradation persist, as droughts, floods, and volcanoes displace people, more and more human beings are culturally vaporized.

            The condition of cultural vaporization, moreover, involves three simultaneous expansions–the increase in human population, the increase in urban dwellers, and the increase in standardization by the extension of centralized, bureaucratic control over larger and larger numbers of people and into more and more details of human life.  Coincident with these expansions is the contraction of total per capita living space and within that contraction a further contraction of unstandardized living space.

            Unstandardized, unoppressed living space can be a space of resistance, armed or unarmed, written or unwritten.  In the US, for example, where the rhetoric of individuality is continually encased in the gestures of conformity, the only unoppressed living space many people have is their bodies.  Thus, resistance to oppression as forced uniformity, as the constraint of standardization without the liberation of individualization–standardization as erasure of difference–appears as tattoos, body piercings, jewelry, hair-do’s, make-up, cars, clothing, music, dialects, food, and gestures.  But the information conveyed by such diversity has no clear or deterministic relation to the initial conditions of the resistors, that is, to their ancestors, their indigenous groups, or their homes.  Resistance by differentiating the appearance of one’s body is a response to anonymity and depersonalization.  It folds the person even further into the strange attractor of change.

            At the same time, however, that modern power is “uniforming” and standardizing all of us, the modern industrial economy is diversifying and differentiating us.  If twenty different kinds of modem, thirty different makes of athletic shoe, fifty different kinds of car, or several hundred different shades of lipstick are not enough, more can be invented and produced.  The operations of modern social power upon humans thus move contemporary social order in two opposite directions simultaneously:  toward greater uniformity and toward greater diversity.

            Expansion of individualized treatments and options occurs with contraction of per capita living space and per capita unoppressed living space.  The operations of oppression may therefore be said to have two asymptotic limits.  In one direction, oppression tends to make everyone the same; in the other direction, it tends to make everyone different.  For example, short hair, low-heeled leather shoes, pants, a shirt, and a windbreaker could describe a male or female from almost any society on earth.  But in the US, where the unisex look is common, everyone of age has a unique social security number, a unique driver’s license number, and many people also have unique phone numbers and addresses.

Transients and Trajectories

            We may further this approach of chaos to social order with work in chaos theory applied to mathematical and physical phenomena that echoes the simultaneous interpenetration of contexts in social life.  We take contexts to be attractors and the habitual practices of contexts to be basins of attraction.  A basin of attraction is a set of initial conditions in phase space which leads to a particular attractor or context.  These initial conditions are usually connected, such as the practices of a group, and form a continuous subspace in some larger cultural phase space.

            Reported by Peter Yam in the March, 1994 issue of Scientific American, numerical experiments conducted by Edward Ott and John C. Sommerer, in which a particle in motion on a “frictional surface is occasionally pushed,” led to indeterminacy as to which of two attractors “the particle would chase, because one basin is riddled with pieces of the other basin.”  According to Yam, the researchers found that, so far from basins simply overlapping each other at their edges or occasionally penetrating each other’s space, “every area in one basin, no matter how small, contained pieces of the other basin within it.”

            This research supports chaos theory as a good representation not only of particular practices but also of contexts which interpenetrate by mixing and folding.  All human practices are accumulations of other practices.  Any one practice can be either decomposed into smaller practices with varying histories or recomposed into larger practices with varying histories.  For example, learning to use a computer keyboard involves the fine coordinations of using different fingers separately as well as the gross skills of using equipment powered by electricity, such as plugging in a plug and turning on a switch.  What we mean by tradition, custom and habit is precisely a layering–mixing/folding–process by which information is compressed and through repeated use and application eroded into shapes and forms that are usable–reproducible–over long periods of time and in different spaces.  The different spaces of guard and prisoner, patient and doctor, or consumer and producer are thus different contexts–attractors–which continuously operate upon and within each other.

            Paradoxically, the decomposability of human practices reflects the nondecomposability criterion of chaotic systems:  “Chaotic systems are indecomposable because they cannot be broken down into two subsystems that do not interact; this arises because of topological transitivity” (Richards 96).  This point can be understood mathematically as the requirement that “[n]onlinear differential equations, and the phenomena or problems they describe, must be seen as a totality, that is, as nondecomposable” (Kiel and Elliott 4; see also, Jaditz 69).  For example, riding a bicycle can be viewed as a combination of large muscle skills using legs and arms, or of small muscle skills using hands, feet, and eyes, or of social sensitivities involving posture, appearance, and style.  Each of these three combinations can be viewed separately as a verbal or even quantitative event.  However, none of them can be lived, experienced, or learned separately.  They all come with each other; they all interact with, impact, and are impacted by each other.  However finely the “subsystem” involved in bicycle riding–or using a computer, singing, swimming, painting, riveting–is described as a separate coherent skill or ability, it is always (already) interacting with all of the other systems.  Indeed, the growing popularity during recent decades of terms such as “interpersonal,” “interaction,” “interconnection,” and “interpenetration” suggests that chaos theory, at least to a contemporary mind and imagination, is a fully credible way to approach understanding social phenomena.

            Viewing both oral and written traditions as different contexts–as interpenetrating sites, as interacting systems–suggests that the subject-matter of social science, whether diachronically elongated or synchronically stacked, can be viewed as dissipative systems.  The continual maintenance, repair, and rebuilding required from bodily cells to clothing to transit systems to software configurations seems to leave little doubt that human living arrangements are predominantly dissipative rather than conservative systems.  In considering challenges to the management of complex systems, De Greene asserts that

            A sociotechnical or techno-economic macrosystem is a dissipative             structure in the sense that high-quality inputs (energy and matter)             are converted to low-quality outputs like heat and waste, with an             increase in disorder and entropy.  Within this overall process, of             course, low-quality raw materials are converted into high-quality             finished products, but these eventually break down, yielding further             entropy. (287)

            If this is reasonable, then it further clarifies the attempt to approach social order conceptually with chaos theory.  As Hao Bai-Lin explains in Chaos II, “it is dissipation that realizes the contraction [compression] of description [information] in a natural way: a vast number of modes die out due to dissipation; only those spanning the attractors need be taken into account in modelling[sic] the system”(6).  Dissipation–depreciation, degeneration, degradation, die-off, extinction–may be seen as the means by which normally and naturally functioning social and natural systems stabilize long-term function against short-term instability caused by proliferation of divergences.  Dissipation, in this sense, according to Hao, “causes the volume representing the initial states in phase space to contract in the process of evolution”(19).

            Oscillations in practices of all kinds are well known and extensively documented (Shils).  Oscillations are identified as such in a field of possibilities whose limits are defined by the tolerance of the practitioners for divergence.  A tolerable range of difference exists, as I describe in detail elsewhere (Cornberg (1)), not as a statistical array or generalization, unless quantification of actions is specifically sought, but as a range of preferences enacted and reenacted in contexts.  The tolerable range of difference defines a phase or state space in social life; enactment and reenactment of preferences constitute trajectories of practice.  When a trajectory does not span the attractor, it dies out.

            The research of Ott and Sommerer also encourages us to seek what we have already found in other ways–nested, embedded, and encaptic contexts or attractors.  The critical attractor of every human group is reproduction.  Examples of human groups are families, tribes, nations, and corporations.  All living things must reproduce for their species to survive but humans have the additional task of reproducing practices not just progeny.  Reproduction, such as human progeny, language transmission, and continuity of traditions, all display information compression.  The information that is needed to complete the practice repeats and varies through completions of the practice both as enactments and as learning events for others.  At any identifiable moment of a practice variation may take place and may be taken up in place of the preceding version.  What has gone before is accessible to the present only through the memory devices of the group.  There is no guarantee from any such memory device, oral, written, or electronic, that other versions have not existed.  Human living groups resist the infinitization of preferences with the compressions of tradition.

            A tolerable range of difference is discernible in all such situations.  Intolerable variations bring various other behaviors which are also practices such as indifference, correction, ridicule, criticism, rejection, denial, censure, repression, censorship, punishment, banishment, conflict and war.  If a practice, regardless of how momentary, and regardless of where it falls within the tolerable range of difference, does not entrain a group’s reproductive energy then it becomes a transient and dies out.  A transient is a trajectory that does not span the attractor long or far enough to repeat or to reproduce.  As Farmer, Ott, and Yorke assert, in an article on the dimension of chaotic attractors, “Loosely speaking, an attractor is something that ‘attracts’ initial conditions from a region around it once transients have died out” (154).  Small towns in industrialized nations typically have a variety of private businesses and public services.  Parameters such as location, economy, tax base, climate, and ethnicity form the basins of attraction which layer–interpenetrate or intersect–each other as determinants of what kinds of activities appear and continue or appear then disappear in such contexts.

            A case study or in-depth interview sample of such a location would constitute a phase portrait of the attractor.  Contained in any particular piece of information in such a portrait would be information about other aspects of the social situation.  We know, for example, that personal interviews about such preferences as political candidates or bond issues can also give us information about language use, gestures, and aspects of social life such as class relations and discrimination.  According to Hao, the “basic idea is: due to nonlinear interactions in the system these [information samples taken at different times] contain information on other variables as well and one should be able to extract this information” from such a series of samples (53).  Such co-presence, simultaneity, or interpenetration of data further illustrates that social power combines compression and persistence in social order.

            Homelessness is a powerful contemporary example and indicator of human living regimes which, with increasing regularity, distinguish between transients and non-transients.  The fact that smaller communities have less incidence of lasting homelessness in comparison with larger towns, cities, and metropolitan areas suggests that the trajectories of homeless people are attracted to basins of human living within which multiple basins–e.g. Ott and Sommerer–contain enough pieces of each other to allow–to tolerate in their range of differences–strongly divergent living arrangements.

            But containing pieces of each other then implies substantial rather than cosmetic discontinuities in social process and structure.  Strongly divergent practices in turn form smaller attractors within the larger attractor of the metropolis.  Patterns of homeness and homelessness would then be expected to show a variety of trajectories of practice, such as correlations between incidence of homelessness and existence of soup kitchens, availability of free shelter, locking of house doors, fencing of land, discriminatory zoning, ownership of small arms, or ownership of guard dogs.  On these social sites, the dying out of a transient can be the death of a person, as the dying out of a practice can be the death of a practitioner.  But given that a transient is a trajectory that does not span the attractor long enough or far enough to repeat, then how long or far is enough?  What causes one practice to persist and another to desist?

Prediction and Social Change

            Stating this question in terms of causation hastens the appearance of the issue of prediction which naturally arises in any attempt to apply to social issues a theory grounded and elaborated in numeric and physical experiments.  It is a fact of increasing significance for all branches of science that most of the systems we encounter are non-linear.  The non-linearity of social order may be understood as the interpenetration of contexts discussed in connection with the research of Ott and Sommerer.  This characteristic of interpenetration bears directly and profoundly on the possibility of using chaos theory mathematically to describe social science data.

            Social science data are derived from social phenomena and social phenomena are contextual.  If contexts interpenetrate, then social science phenomena have always already begun, in multiple non-trivial senses, before they are observed, recorded, and quantified in any particular social science sample.  The starting and ending periods of observations are dictated to the social scientist by the available data.  Assumptions can be made about how a particular person or situation got to where it is when observed, but those assumptions cannot give us precise, unique, quantitative conditions.  Since this situation obtains throughout the analysis of social science data, it is impossible to determine initial conditions of such phenomena with the uniqueness and precision necessary to use the established mathematical measures of chaos, such as spectral analysis, Lyapunov exponents, autocorrelation functions, power law distributions, and others (Kiel and Elliot 8-10, 51, 53).  If these calculations are not possible then it is impossible to assert with mathematical certainty and clarity that chaos exists in any particular set of social science data.

            Besides this limitation on the calculability of chaos measures, chaos theory has one other feature which strongly limits its quantitative applicability to social science data:  homogeneity.

            Contained perturbed fluids, amplified electrical charges, atmospheric gases, and chemicals in liquid mixtures all display a homogeneity which is precisely amenable to mathematical description but which is found nowhere in social life.  Mathematical manipulations, such as the construction of the Mandelbrot set and the generation of the Feigenbaum number, also have homogeneity as variations of the symbol system of mathematics.  However, “very rarely, if ever, are social systems comprised of identical components with highly homogeneous behavior” (Dendrinos 240-1).  The only way in which a comparable homogeneity can be obtained in social science data is to quantify some aspect of social life such as divorce rates, voter choices, and incidences of disease.  Once specific quantities are obtained then simulations can be constructed which show characteristics of chaos.

            However, the simulations all posit arbitrary, artificial initial conditions which do not correspond to or represent the ongoingness, the historicity, or the livingness of the phenomena from which the quantitative data are extracted.  For example, in a presentation of his universal map for studying the dynamics of human settlement activity, Dendrinos points out that “a change in parameter values or initial conditions can result in a new frame, m, potentially characterized by a qualitatively different dynamic…” (253).  No doubt there is no end to the abstract possibilities in such a model.  Indeed, according to Dendrinos, “one of the weaknesses” in current uses of chaos theory for mathematical modeling in economics is “that under slight but proper modifications in specification, these models can reproduce almost anything that the analyst wishes to produce through theoretical deduction” (238)!

            But what constitutes the initial conditions of human settlement or even of human action in the first place?  Is an initial condition the fact that a shaman read a bird’s entrails and directed a group to settle in a certain cave?  Or was it the fact that the group had only two days of food left and winter was coming on?  Or was it the appearance of a familiar star in a strange area of the night sky?  Or was it competition between a chief and a sub-chief over who was the best provider for the group?  Suppose that the latter was taken as the initial condition that accounted for the group settling in a particular cave.  In what sense, then, was that the initial condition?  Does calling it an “initial condition” imply that it had no history?  Isn’t it possible that the chief allowed the sub-chief to select that particular cave at that particular time because the chief had already decided to retire from active leadership, or because the sub-chief had promised certain material rewards?  In either case, there is another condition behind, before, prior to, or folded into the initial one.  Indeed, how is it possible to give any kind of precise meaning to the term “initial” in such a situation?

            There is a pervasive silence in the literature on the fundamental question of how to adequately and effectively translate the notion of initial conditions from physical and numeric experiments to social science observation, sampling, and description.  The appearance of chaos in mathematical simulations using quantitative social science data must therefore be viewed with extreme caution.  Certainly dynamics with chaotic characteristics can be generated from many different kinds of quantified social science data.  But is the chaos an artifact of the simulation or is it an explanation of the lived reality of social life from which the quantitative data are extracted?

            This kind of consideration has led Harvey and Reed to assert the following rule as their number one caveat about applying chaos theory to social science:

            1.  Predictive, statistical, and iconological modes of chaos modeling             should be restricted to those ontological levels in which collective             social phenomena can be legitimately treated as a statistically             aggregated phenomenon, that is, as being composed of additive,             numerable, and interchangeable individual units. (314)

            Indeed, since improvements in concrete social forecasting have not yet been achieved using chaos theory (Berry and Kim 216; Brown 128; Jaditz 86; Rosser 209), I am inclined to agree at this time with Dendrinos summary comment that the “single most important contribution mathematical chaos has made [to social science] is to demonstrate the possible presence of new dynamical features in social systems that theoreticians had never addressed before” (238).  Hence my purpose here in showing the radical utility of chaos theory for understanding social order rather than for describing social science data mathematically.

Extended Applications

            Social order which involves mixing and folding and goes in the extreme to cultural vaporization fits the definition of non-linearity and illustrates interpenetration of contexts.  Social order viewed in this way is chaotic.  Chaos as social order also provides a way of understanding the infinite degrees of freedom that characterize human actions.

            The infinitization of human freedom is not due only to some inherent characteristic of human nature, character or personality.  It is a function of the fact that human choices are always situated in contexts which interpenetrate to indefinitely large and complicated extents in time and space.  Each piece of another context or basin of attraction provides more scope for choice and each different piece brings more pieces with it.  Moreover, it seems clear that the only linear systems in social life are those like railroad tracks and contracts that require human will and energy in an attempt to establish and maintain order without variation, that is, without mixing and folding.  Boycotts, strikes, renegotiations of contracts and collusions between prisoners and guards show, however, that even in these high stakes’ social contexts there is no guarantee of linearity.

            When we leave the regimes of established and enforced lines, channels, and hallways and enter edges, transition zones, and liminal spaces, moreover, initial conditions of human trajectories cannot be determined with any certainty.  If they are, then there has been a deliberate and arbitrary reduction–collapse, renormalization–of degrees of freedom experienced socially as options.  Even with such a reduction, the infinities of preference open to humans throughout society reintroduce uncertainties which must again be reduced in order to satisfy the requirements of linearity.  This rhythmic layering of recursive oscillations, of mixing and folding operations, and of deliberate attempts at reductive linearization can be seen in four concrete social situations:  1.  Endangered Tongues; 2.  Moral Basins; 3.  Assassination; and, 4.  Cyberspace.

1.  Endangered Tongues.  Off and on since the late 70′s, I have done various kinds of projects with the Athabascan Indians in Interior Alaska.  One of these projects involved constructing a survey to gather the opinions of Tribal members on questions of indigenous language preservation.              There are nine different Athabascan tongues still in use in some form in the Interior of Alaska.  As a land area, the Interior is slightly smaller than the state of Texas, contains the major drainages of the Yukon, Tanana, Koyukuk, Porcupine, and Chandalar Rivers, and supports over forty villages–Tribes–whose inhabitants derive ethnically from earlier Athabascan peoples with mixtures of Inupiat and Yupik Eskimo, and Aleut Indian.  Most of the villages are accessible only by air, water, or snow covered ice.  The villages range in population from under fifty to nearly a thousand.  All of them have some kind of electronic communication with other villages and with towns and cities on the state road system and in other parts of the world.

            All of them have some kind of public school facility in which the official language is English.  English is also the official language of commerce, public affairs, and most recreational activities such as basketball and bingo.  In most Interior villages, only a small number of older people retain anything like fluency in a Native language, with a larger number being partial speakers some of whom have learned the language not in a natural family interaction but in some kind of classroom setting.

            On the basis of this situation, Michael Krauss, who has directed the Alaska Native Language Center at the University of Alaska Fairbanks, in Fairbanks, Alaska, for the past two decades, predicts that all of these languages will be extinct by 2055.  Krauss qualifies this prediction by the inclusion of only native speakers, that is, those who have learned the language as their first language from birth.  This qualification takes into account the fact well-attested by older Athabascan speakers that sounds once used in these highly agglutinative, rhythmical, and guttural languages have already disappeared or are too difficult for contemporary speakers to reproduce.  Along with a dying out of vocal ranges, the disappearance of a once well-marked distinction between a formal style of oratory and ceremony, and a vernacular style of everyday affairs, is affirmed by the same speakers.  The appearance of a “village English” further attests to the mixing ground with English in which the Athabascan languages are fading into a silent hue of memory.

            It is instructive, before trying to tie any of this to chaos theory, to note that the Interior Athabascans used to make rope from spruce roots, and heavy sewing twine–babiche–from moose skin.  They also used to catch fish in bent willow traps, shoot birds with bows and arrows, and kill charging bears on wooden spears with fire-hardened points.  Most of the older, non-metal technology has either completely disappeared or become pastime, show-piece, museum piece, or story line.  The newer technology, based on the metal, chemical, and plastic industries, has made all of the older tasks much safer in terms of risk to life and limb, easier and more efficient in terms of human exertion, more reliable in terms of success per attempt, and more productive in terms of quantities gained.  The newer Athabascan languages, derived from the older ones and adapted to a context in which information processing and transfer are far more important than reverence, ceremony, and maintenance of taboo, seem also to be becoming easier to learn and simpler in use.

            The attractor of Athabascan culture has changed.  Its phase space now includes multi-story office buildings with advanced electronic equipment in Fairbanks, satellite dishes with color TVs, and the latest in snowmachines and outboard motors in the villages.  The trajectories of an older, slower, more complicated language, and an older, slower, less reliable material technology, with hunting and gathering as their basin of attraction, do not span the new attractor.  The result is that they become transients with varying degrees and kinds of “death.”

            Languages that span the national and international artistic, political, economic, and military attractors are English, French, German, Spanish, Mandarin Chinese, Russian, Arabic, and Japanese.  The history of each language shows a contraction of state space with a subsequent decrease in diversity.  A contraction decreases diversity because, as transients die out, there are fewer possible trajectories on a particular attractor.  The unification of the Chinese language, for example, began over two thousand years ago.  The creation of a standard English, French, and Spanish was also achieved at the expense of many local variations some of which, like the Catalan and Basque languages, became smaller attractors with sufficient local energy to survive, but many of which have long since ceased to exist.  It is only in the last decade, according to my own sources in the region, that Athabascans of Interior Alaska have begun to consider unification as a language preservation strategy.

2.  Moral Basins.  Features of linguistic basins are displayed by moral basins.  The last century of life in Taipei, Taiwan provides a stunning example of cross-cultural contact and mixing.  The moral experience of young people in Taipei was the subject of my dissertation as well as of two articles ((2) and (3)) which condensed the content of the dissertation for a wider audience.  I take the position that the moral experience of young people in contemporary urban Taiwan–Taipei–can best be understood in terms of three interacting sites:  the family, the street, and the school.  On the basis of historical considerations that include the perdurant streams of classical Chinese and the intervening streams of European, Japanese, and American civilizations, the moral basin of each context or attractor can be characterized as family/hierarchy, street/fluidity, and school/competition.

            When young people in Taipei traverse, inhabit, and (re)create each site in the course of a day, they are the bearers of the pieces of each basin that recursively layer one another in ongoing oscillations of attitude and behavior.  They carry from the family a hierarchically ordered deference to older siblings and adults into the street and the school.  They carry from the school an egalitarian competition into the school and the family.  From the street they carry a fluid, individualizing sense of freedom and responsibility into both the family and the school.  As layered, recursive carriers of practices who are continually impacted by their peers and by adults, young people live social reality as porous.

            Porosity can be understood as a metric on the state space of society.  The degree of porosity–interpenetration, mixing/folding– is a good index of the degree of chaos in social life.

            The porosity of the space, moreover, makes it holographic in the sense indicated by Ott and Sommerer’s research showing that every basin contained pieces of other basins.  Connecting trails to other attractors in the social order of Taipei can be found in a small portion of that order, e.g., a classroom, a living room, or a bus stop.  For example, while bus riders in Taipei usually do not line up for the bus door, students in school uniforms, although off school grounds and out of the jurisdiction of school disciplinarians, often do line up.  However, relations among attractors and pieces of attractors are rarely linear; they are fractal in the sense of having fractured or fractional relations among parts rather than being integrally related in linear dimensions.  Porous social space is holofractic.  The possibility of prediction within a particular basin of attraction, such as a family or a school, decreases with the increase in porosity of the social life in which the smaller basin is embedded.

            Taipei has been one of the most cosmopolitan cities in Asia for almost a century.  A decrease in older indigenous Taiwanese or imported Chinese patterns has been happening simultaneously with an increase in patterns from other ethnic sources, whether these be technology, language, dress, dance, manners, religion, or marriage customs.  In language, for example, the written Chinese used in Taipei has become more complicated both because of the differing kinds of characters used there and on the mainland and because of the accretion of elements from other languages.  Again, as in Interior Alaska, a contraction of phase space, which signals the dying out of certain trajectories of practice that do not span the attractor of social change, happens together with an expansion of phase space as a birth in new contexts of new trajectories of practice representing various mixtures of the exogenous and the indigenous.

            An application of chaos theory to social issues, as exemplified by Taiwan and Interior Alaska, supports the findings of historical linguistics that there is no simple, inevitable path from older, more complex to newer simpler languages, or vice versa.  It also supports the findings of social science research that the increase in options for attitude and behavior is one of the main events in the complex changes in social order of the last century collectively known as modernization.  This is not a linear decrease in options until some point after which new, more plentiful options can be and are introduced.  Rather, there is a decrease in certain kinds of options which releases cultural energy for a simultaneous increase in other kinds.

            This crucible of contact with exogenous power which constrains and liberates, represses and releases, and destroys and amplifies indigenous power contains the interactions whose unraveling in theory will determine what kinds of predictability, if any, are possible in such spaces.  It seems unquestionable that a strong correlation exists between the availability of culturally unbound or unencumbered power, either coming in from outside sources or released from inside sources, and the appearance of chaotic cultural regimes.  Whether the culturally free power takes the form of guns, drugs and money, or communication, transportation and production technologies, it does not automatically and smoothly reproduce indigenous practices and patterns.  Its introduction becomes an intervention that induces interference patterns.  The interference patterns fold, bifurcate, and diverge into multiple orders or basins which, in a city such as Taiwan, can include new millionaires, depression and suicide, new environmental activism, unprecedented street crime, a clean, quiet electrorail system, and some of the worst air pollution in the world.  As the unprecedented, the novel, the new, and the unheard of increase in extent and frequency, complexity becomes chaos.

3.  Assassination.  A brief example from another country comes from Mexico, shortly after the assassination of PRI Presidential Candidate Luis Donaldo Colosio, in Tijuana.  Interviewed for the New York Times, March 27th issue, by Tim Golden, Jesús Cantú, “an editor whose independent newspaper” had been “firebombed two weeks” previously, shared a widespread feeling that the assassination had shown weakness in Mexico’s political system “that once seemed indestructible.”  In terms of chaos, such a change is emergent porosity.  The laminar state space of Mexico has articulated into turbulence with a dramatic increase in possible trajectories of social and political practice.  It is no accident or surprise, from the standpoint of chaos theory, that the Mayan uprising in the south happened shortly before the assassination.  As Cantú remarked, “You feel now like anything could happen” (Golden 3).

4.  Cyberspace.  The electronic trip is a dependent phenomenon–when the power goes out the trip stops.  As a dependent phenomenon it must constantly be recreated.  The qualities it has are the qualities given it by those who take, make, and use it–Aryans make it Aryan, environmentalists make it environmental, investors make it investing.  It does not have the independent existence of the natural, hardwired software known as imagination.  Why then does cyberspace exist at all?

            This question is easier to answer on the streets of Taipei than on the tundra of Alaska.  Taiwan has the second highest population density in the world.  When population density combines with multiple, flexible, increasing avenues of expression, new human spaces result.  When population density combines with limited physical space, such as an island like Taiwan, a nation like the United States, or a planet like the earth, compression takes place.

            Compression involves a multitude of actions upon actions, of foldings and mixings.  Compression destroys information and creates information.  In both processes, certain kinds of space are created in order not only to accommodate the destructive and creative processes but also to contain the destroyed and created information.  Where does a document go when it is trashed?  Where does a document go when it is cached?  Where does a document go when it is stored or saved?  Where does a document go when it is emailed, faxed, printed, or mailed?  Each process requires a certain kind of space.

            Compression creates space by contracting quantity.  Compression of human beings creates more and more finely faceted human spaces.  Simultaneously, the increase in human beings, the expansion of their personal spatial horizons, and the increase in their physical possessions create needs for more living space.  Humans now need more living space.  Many people are responding to compression by moving to more and more remote land areas, to outer space, and to the bottoms of oceans.

            Cyberspace is a new kind of living space which combines the remoteness of satellite transmission with the intimacy of home computers, and the standardization of hardware and software with the individualization of preferences in nearly every aspect of the medium.  It is continuous with play space, art space, recreational space, and ceremonial space.  Certainly cyberspace is a medium of communication.  Email is continuous with other communication media such as speaking, singing, dancing, signal fires, drums, letters, messengers, telephones, microwave, and fax.  But email is only a small part of cyberspace.  Impersonal, privately controlled, data transmission and self-stimulating cyberplay are two other major uses which show that cyberspace grows from a need for new kinds of unoppressed living space.  Indeed, the resistance of cyberusers to formal regulation shows how continuous cyberspace is with the traditional individual spaces of play, recreation, and expression.

The changes described above in languages, morals, politics, and human space are not linear, laminar, and sequential.  They are like a quiver of arrows being shot in all directions at once.  The basic attractor of reproduction in a cross-cultural context illuminates this phenomenon because people must continue to speak, dress, marry and so forth in order to survive regardless of the precise ethnic stamp of the language, clothing, or customs.  But if in the process of reproduction, available power increases at an increasing speed and available options multiply more quickly than older options can transform, then the phase space contracts and expands simultaneously with some trajectories dying out and others spanning the new attractor.

The older practices whose enactment connects indigenous power with exogenous power span the new attractor.  Those which do not, not even as museum or tourism curiosities, die out.  The newer practices whose enactment connects exogenous power with indigenous power span the new attractor.  Those which do not are resisted and excluded.  How long is long enough and how far is far enough?  In terms of human living arrangements it is a question of how people use the various kinds of power that are available to them.

            In physical terms, the onset of chaos in physical experiments is reached by means of adding certain kinds of energy to systems–chemical, mechanical, electrical, etc.–that are capable of different regimes of behavior.  These physical systems do not get to chaos by themselves.  They get there by way of receiving and processing energy as the quiescent water described above gets to boiling by receiving and processing thermal energy.  They are physically driven, deterministic systems.  They have regimes of behavior whose characteristics, including transitions to turbulence and to chaos, are determined by manipulation of certain parameters such as temperature, speed of rotation, and voltage.

            Numeric systems are more difficult to describe in concrete terms but they too are deterministic.  In processes such as the generation of the Mandelbrot set or of Feigenbaum’s constant, a finite numerical entity is subjected to repeated recursive layerings or foldings until typically bifurcatory oscillatory behavior occurs.  Again, the numbers do not get to chaos by themselves.  The “energy” of manipu

About the Author

Jewelry Making : How to Rivet Jewelry

Proxxon 28608 Precision Vise FMZ with Clamp $31.81 The ball and socket design of this German engineered bench vise, shown here in a horizontal position, allows the ability to position this vise in virtually any orientation. This vise also has flexible mounting options built right in to its design. It can be securely clamped to a table or bench, or screwed directly to a work bench. This vise also makes using our riveting system even easier to use. …

1/16 Dia. 3/32 Long Aluminum Rivet $4.75 1/16″ Dia. 3/32″ Long Aluminum Rivet Use the 1/16″ Rivet Piercing/Setting Tool to set these rivets…

1/16 Dia. 1/16 Long Copper Rivet $4.75 1/16″ Dia. 1/16″ Long Copper Rivet Use the 1/16″ Rivet Piercing/Setting Tool to set these rivets…

Metalsmith Essentials: Riveting & Cold Connections DVD $39.99 You asked, how could we not deliver? Metalsmith Essentials is back with another 2-disc set. This time, it’s all about favorite no-heat techniques: cold connections. Volume 1, Basic Fabrication flew off the shelves and started a metalsmith revolution. Now you can join artist and experienced metalsmith Helen Driggs in the next set of 10 watch-and-learn lessons as she shows you step by step how to …

1/16 Dia. 1/4 Long Brass Rivet $5.25 1/16″ Dia. 1/4″ Long Brass Rivet Use the 1/16″ Rivet Piercing/Setting Tool to set these rivets…

Stamped Metal Jewelry: Creative Techniques and Designs for Making Custom Jewelry $16.30 Metal stamping is one of the hottest trends in metal jewelry. Using purchased metal stamps and sterling silver blanks, you can personalize your metal jewelry designs with words, textures, and creative designs. Lisa Niven Kelly, creator of the online Beaducation workshops and website, specializes in the technique and has been teaching stamping for more than six years to enthusiastic students. Altho…

Making Metal Jewelry: Projects, Techniques, Inspiration $6.00 No soldering is required to make these metal necklaces, rings, bracelets, and earrings; they’re cold-connected, or crafted with such easy-to-learn skills as piercing, sawing, riveting, and joining, making them perfect for the beginning jeweler. Yet the results look completely professional. Work with a variety of metals in sheets, wires, and tubes. Create your own chains, ear wires, clasps, and o…

Wrap, Stitch, Fold & Rivet: Making Designer Metal Jewelry (Lark Jewelry Books) $12.47 Making gorgeous handcrafted jewelry can be an amazingly simple process that even beginners will quickly master—as long as they have this guide by their side. Written by an experienced artist and teacher, and generously illustrated with attractive how-to photos and drawings, it demonstrates a wealth of easy techniques in superb detail. Twenty dazzling projects—including a twisted wire cho…

2.00 Carat Oval Cut Aquamarine & Diamond 14Kt Yellow Gold Ring $2265 This riveting gemstone and diamond ring will awe your visual senses. Its striking look is enhanced by a gorgeous oval cut aquamarine stone. This genuine aquamarine has a weight of 1.50 carats and radiates with an exceptional color hue with an impressive clarity. The shank of the ring features glittering princess cut diamonds that have a total weight of .50 carats. These diamonds range in clarity from Vs2-Si1 with a color grade ranging from H-I. This wonderful ring is made of 14kt. yellow gold.

1.80 Carat Diamond Milgrain Design 14Kt White Gold Eternity Band $3539 This riveting diamond eternity band will move your spirits with its sensational design. Beautiful round cut diamonds are set all the way around the band and on the side profile of the ring to create a lasting impression. These diamonds have a total combined weight of 1.80 carats and ranges in clarity from Vs2-Si1 with a color grade ranging from H-I. The edges of the ring are accented by small milgrain designs for an alluring look. This wonderful piece measures 3mm thick and is made of 14kt. white gold with a total gold weight of 4.90 grams.

1.01 Carat Selena Diamond 14Kt White Gold Engagement Ring $3956 This riveting diamond engagement ring features clean lines that is refreshing and uncluttered. Its sleekness is highlighted by a glittering radiant cut diamond with a weight of 1.01 carats. This beautiful diamond is bezel set to offer the utmost protection of your investment. The exceptional radiant cut diamond has a clarity of Si1 with a color grade of G. This rings design makes it the perfect candidate for those who seek a design that doesn’t interfere with their active lifestyle. The clean design gives this ring a timeless appeal that will be enjoyed for years to come. This wonderful piece is made of 14kt. white gold with a total gold weight of 4.68 grams.

Jewelry Making $24.95 Making jewelry at a professional level has never been so simple. The inexpensive materials and cleverly adapted traditional methods featured int his book make success inevitable. A book for all skill levels. Every technique is photographed step-by-step with thorough explanation of common pitfalls and how to avoid them. Includes more than 50 original and stunning projects such as an octagonal ring, domed ear studs, a forged choker, and a brass bangle. The valuable introduction presents basic skills of simple jewelry making, how to build a collection of tools, types of metal to use, and the best design techniques.

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 6.5 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V6.5

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 7 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V7

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 7.5 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V7.5

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 8 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V8

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 8.5 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V8.5

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 5 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V5

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 5.5 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V5.5

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 6 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V6

Amethyst Pendant with Diamonds 2/5 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold with Chain $129 Purple amethyst abounds in this striking pendant necklace display that additionally features a bordering arrangement of two riveting diamonds set in radiant white gold. Gold chain included. SKU: 02JP70791AMW

Citrine Earrings with Diamonds 7/10 Carat (ctw) in 10K Yellow Gold $129 Sensational citrine, Novembers glorious birthstone, creates riveting yellow gold gemstone earrings. Sparkling diamonds comeplete the look. Citrine weight equals 7/10 carat (ctw). SKU: 01CH80448CT

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 10 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V10

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 9 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V9

Garnet Heart Ring with Diamonds 1.43 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold, Size 9.5 $249 Three heart shaped garnet gemstones imbue this riveting white gold heart ring, additionally housing an arrangement of sparkling diamonds. View item video above. SKU: 08JP68972GAW:V9.5

Aquamarine Gemstone Drop Earrings 3/8 Carat (ctw) in 10K White Gold $79 Airy aquamarine is the glorious gemstone of choice in these riveting white gold earrings you can wear to any occasion. High style at incredible value. Total gemstone weight is 3/8 carat (ctw). SKU: 01ES45486AQW

2.19 Carat Shylay Diamond 14Kt White Gold Engagement Ring $3233 Express your love to that special person with this inviting diamond engagement ring. Its riveting design features a three stone ring look in the middle with a beautiful .62 carat round brilliant cut diamond in the center. This eye-catching diamond has a clarity of Vs2 with a color grade of I. On either side are round cut diamonds to complete the three stone ring look. These side round diamonds have a total combined weight of .32 carats. The glittering open v shank features pave set round cut diamonds both on the top and side profile of the ring. These shimmering diamonds have a total weight of 1.25 carats. All the side round diamonds range in clarity from Vs2-Si1 with a color grade ranging from H-I. The dramatic look of this fine ring will generate plenty of positive comments. This wonderful piece measures 8mm wide and is made of 14kt. white gold with a total metal weight of 5.90 grams.

5.28 Carat Invisible Set Princess & Graduating Baguette Diamond Anniversary Band $18769 Exquisite in demeanor and bold in style, this impressive diamond anniversary band commands immediate attention. Its riveting design and incomparable nature features dazzling princess cut diamonds that are invisible set in the center. These invisible set diamonds create a fiery display that will delight your eyes. The princess diamonds have a total combined weight of 3.78 carats. Along the edges of the ring, glittering baguette cut diamonds are channel set to accentuate the elegance of this ring. These baguettes graduate slightly in length as it contours along the top of the ring. The baguettes have a total weight of 1.50 carats. Both princess and baguette diamonds are very fine cut ranging in clarity from Vs1-Vs2 with a color grade ranging from G-H. This stunning piece is made of 18kt. white gold with a total metal weight of 20.00 grams.

2.95 Carat Gisselle2 Diamond 14Kt White Gold Engagement Ring $4353 Prepare yourself to be blown away by the most riveting diamond engagement ring and wedding band set that you will ever see. You eyes will be totally entranced by the beautiful .75 carat princess cut diamond that is semi-tension set so that it shines with unrestricted brilliance. The center diamond hovers above all other stones in this design and features a clarity of Si1 with a color grade of H. On the side of the engagement ring are smaller princess cut diamonds that glitter like tiny fireworks. These diamonds are set in a star setting or kite set to give it a dramatic look. There are 1.10 carats of princess cut diamonds on the side creating a vibrant display that will surely fetch plenty of compliments. The custom wedding band that accompanies this ring feature an additional 1.10 carats of princess cut diamonds. Again, these diamonds are star set to match the design of the main ring. The side diamonds on both rings have a clarity of Vs2-Si1 with a color grade ranging from H-I. Each of the spectacular rings measure 6mm or 12mm total when worn together. This set is made of 14kt. white gold with a total metal weight of 11.10 grams.

4.11 Carat Cushion Cut Blue Sapphire & Diamond 18Kt White Gold Ring $11259 Grabbing your attention is this riveting gemstone and precious diamond ring. You’ll be compelled to look at this ring at every chance and be mesmerized by the gorgeous blue cushion cut natural sapphire in the center. This captivating sapphire has a weight of 3.01 carats and glows with a beautiful and rich blue color hue. The vivid color will surely attract plenty of attention while double claw prongs hold it securely in place. Surrounding the center sapphire are glittering round pave set diamonds that shimmers profusely. The pave diamonds around the halo of the ring continues down the split shank where three bezel set diamonds are set on either side. There are a total of 1.10 carats worth of sparkling round diamonds in this work of art. These diamonds are very fine cut and all range in clarity from Vs1-Vs2 with a color grade ranging from G-H. The side profile of the ring features delicate cut out designs that enhances the beauty of this ring and creates a breathtaking look. This sensational piece measures 12.5mm wide on the top and 7mm wide at the shank. The ring is crafted in 18kt. white gold with a total metal weight of 7.50 grams.

1.30 Carat Jalisa Diamond 14Kt White Gold Engagement Ring $1578 This wonderful diamond engagement ring exhibits an elegance that will reverberate through the room. Its striking composure features princess cut diamonds that are invisible set in the middle. These invisible set diamonds give the appearance of a solid center stone for a fraction of the cost. As a matter of fact, it has the same diameter or equivalent in size to a solid three quarter carat stone. On the side, additional princess cut diamonds are channel set down the shank for a riveting look. There are a total of .90 carats worth of beautiful princess diamonds on both the top and shank of the ring. The side profile of the ring shows off pave set round cut diamonds on the top contours of the ring. Underneath the center section of the ring are three bezel set round cut diamonds. There are .40 carats of round cut diamonds in this graceful piece. The diamonds all range in clarity from Vs2-Si1 with a color grade ranging from H-I. This ring measures 4mm wide and is made of 14kt. white gold with a total metal weight of 4.81 grams.

1.78 Carat Inari Diamond 14Kt White Gold Engagement $4154 Hold back your excitement as your eyes are mesmerized by the riveting design of this diamond engagement ring. Your attention will be affixed on the fiery focal point, a beautiful 1.01 carat princess cut diamond. This diamond shines with a Vs2 clarity and I color grade. The side shoulders of the ring are elevated so that it proudly shows off the invisible set princess diamonds on either side. Round cut diamonds are pave set on the elevated shoulder and down the open split shank. Additional round diamonds are pave set along the side profile of the ring. The princess diamonds have a total of .24 carats and the side round diamonds total .53 carats. These diamonds all range in clarity from Vs2-Si1 with a color grade ranging from H-I. This ring features a bold design that will entice the curiosity of everyone while delighting their visual senses. This wonderful piece measures 7mm at its widest point and is made of 14kt. white gold with a total metal weight of 6.10 grams.

Garnet Earrings with Diamonds 9/10 Carat (ctw) in 10K Yellow Gold $129 Sultry red garnet, Januarys sensational birthstone, dominates the glittering landscape in these riveting yellow gold earrings, while a small collection of diamonds also make their presence felt. Total weight of the garnet is 9/10 carat(ctw). SKU: 01CH80448GA

Bead And Wire Jewelry Exposed $22.95 Over 50 Designer Beaded and Wire Jewelry Projects Inside. In Bead and Wire Jewelry Exposed, well-known designers Katie Hacker, Fernando DaSilva and Margot Potter offer over 50 high-fashion jewelry pieces made using unique techniques that reveal typically hidden components such as beading wire, cording, findings, tubing and chain as the central focus of the design. While the pieces may look complex, the techniques are simple enough for beginners – yet sophisticated enough for the veteran jewelry crafter. A comprehensive getting started section provides information on the supplies, tools and techniques you and 39;ll need to make all of the projects in the book.

The Art Of Resin Jewelry $24.95 Best-selling author Sherri Haab shows you how simple it is to use layering, casting and mixed media techniques to make vintage and contemporary jewelry. Projects range from simple to sophisticated. Packed with tips on tools, supplies, finishing, and creating special effects, this is a beautiful and practical introduction to an exciting art. DVD features hands-on demonstrations of 3 additional projects plus a gallery of inspiring jewelry designs. The projects seen in the additional images are by artist and author Sherri Haab.

Jewelry Making For Fun And Profit $19.95 Includes 7 money-making projects you can create at home. Learn the elegant art of jewelry making. Jewelry Making For Fun and Profit was written with two purposes in mind to teach you the basics of this fun craft and to show you how to turn these new skills into cash. Whether you and 39;ve been crafting for years or are just getting started, you and 39;ll learn The benefits and enjoyment of jewelry making The right materials, tools, and equipment to use How to create a special crafting place in your home Ways to sell your creations at craft shows, shops, and other outlets Craft-business basics, including pricing and record keeping And much more.

Metal Jewelry Made Easy $22.95 Learn to Make Unique Metal Crafted Jewelry Metalsmithing can be a daunting task, especially to the beginner. This beautifully photographed, comprehensive guide provides crafters of all levels with a gentle, user-friendly approach to substantial metal jewelry-making skills. After reviewing the fundamentals of jewelry design, raw materials, and safety in the studio, readers are introduced to tools for cutting, drilling, forming, soldering, polishing, and more. Next, they will learn a variety of techniques including piercing, stamping, forging, annealing, oxidizing, casting, and even setting stones, enabling them to create 25 stunning and professional-looking projects. 128 full-color pages. Hardcover.

Easy Beaded Jewelry $21.95 Now, beaders can create expensive-looking original beaded jewelry that reflects their personal style. Easy Beaded Jewelry features more than 75 elegant projects for jewelry that would be expensive to buy in a boutique, but can be made for much less – and many projects can be made within an afternoon, some even within an hour. Beginners will learn the basics of techniques, selecting materials and understanding design, style, color and texture. Step-by-step instructions and helpful illustrations guide readers through creating gorgeous necklaces, bracelets, anklets, earrings, chokers and more. It also features an exploration of today and 39;s jewelry market, a pictionary of components and tools beaders will need, and artists and 39; profiles with helpful hints from the experts on creating personalized pieces.

Ubisoft Style Lab: Jewelry $20.99 16581 Easy-to-Use Tools Use the stylus to draw out lengths of chain or wire, decorate beads by cutting, drawing or painting for a layered approach Run Your Own Jewelry Boutique Interact with customers, arrange displays of your unique creations in the window, and build your business Share your Creations Welcome your friends into your boutique wirelessly, trade jewelry and beads with friends, and showcase your designs in the online Style Lab gallery Create Incredible Designer Jewelry. Design stunning bracelets, necklaces, and earrings using a variety of colored, faceted beads and darling charms, including letter charms. Order, own, and wear your unique in-game creations when you upload them to the Style Lab website. Designing Game Nintendo DS RP (Rating Pending) Software Style Lab: Jewelry Ubisoft Ubisoft Entertainment www.ubi.com

Elegant Wire Jewelry $17.95 Secrets to Creating Beautiful Wire Jewelry — Now in Soft Cover Create stylish, contemporary jewelry with a repertoire of simple techniques and basic, inexpensive tools. Then learn to customize the designs by combining techniques and adding beads and embellishments. As you explore the creative process and methods, you will create Silver Tendril Earrings, a Hip2B Square Pin, a Breezy Autumn Pendant and 22 other contemporary projects. By coiling, wrapping, hammering and looping wire, it and 39;s possible to make an infinite variety of spectacular designs. Projects shown below are from this inspiring book and created by author and artist Kathy Frey.

Traveler’s Jewelry Chest $99.98 Classic and masculine, the design of this handcrafted jewelry chest is a real treasure in high-quality wood and brass. Inspired by an early twentieth-century traveler’s chest, it features a large convenient drawer lined in plush felt, three small drawers and a larger compartment. Use it to store your cufflinks collection, small tools or other treasures. It measures 15″ x 8½” x 13″.

Magical Metal Clay Jewelry $24.95 Learn to Create Pure Silver Jewelry the Easy Way Informative guide shows you how to make astounding designs using simple techniques and tools. Over 250 full color photographs and clear instructions take you through more than 20 design possibilities, including braiding, carving, setting stones and more. Also learn how to embellish with gold, incorporate glass cabochons and add color with resin. The first image below illustrates one creative metal clay technique, mold making, discussed in this book.

Cooper Tools Cooper Tools Mini Soldering Iron SP12 $12.88 Mini soldering iron 7? long, less tip Lightweight pencil-thin, ideal for fine soldering and hobby work 12W Can be used for small intricate jobs such as electronics kits, model railways and jewelry making Brand #: Cooper Tools SP12 UPC: 037103479716 Keywords: soldering iron

Bangle Jewelry Box $30 Bangle Jewelry Box

Pendant Jewelry Box $20 Pendant Jewelry Box

Dangle Earrings Jewelry Box $20 Dangle Earrings Jewelry Box

Making Metal Jewelry $14.95 Projects, Techniques, Inspiration No soldering is required to make these metal necklaces, rings, bracelets, and earrings; they and 39;re cold-connected, or crafted with such easy-to-learn skills as piercing, sawing, riveting, and joining, making them perfect for the beginning jeweler. Yet the results look completely professional. Work with a variety of metals in sheets, wires, and tubes. Create your own chains, ear wires, clasps, and other findings from wire jump rings. Learn metal texturing and finishing techniques such as chasing, etching, and adding a patina. Find out how to make simple settings for pearls, beads, and stones. Then set your creativity free on projects like a Circle Brooch with Thorn Clasp; Layered Cuff Bracelet, and Polka Dot Tube Earrings.

Silver Wire Jewelry $14.95 Master Braided, Knit and Coil Wire Jewelry in this Project Book With a coil, braid, and twist, plus other ingeniously easy techniques, these magnificent silver bracelets, necklaces, and earrings take lovely shape. Each of the 99 projects, illustrated with color photos and diagrams, shows exactly why wire jewelry has become today and 39;s hot craft. All that and 39;s needed are very basic tools and this helpful advice on making coils, plying wires, stretching out the coils to form graceful waves, joining rings to make elegant chains, fashioning wire into figure eights, incorporating beads, or creating crocheted adornments. Pretty earrings come in a delicate teardrop or corkscrew style, a flat braided necklace has a unique, oxidized finish, and the traditional chain mail bracelet features freshwater pearls. Every piece in this handsome collection is graded for difficulty. 80 pages hardcover.

Mixed Metal Jewelry Workshop $12.93 Open your world of creative options to include more than simple silver metal clay. This 128 hardcover book includes 20 projects combining wire, metal mesh, sheet metal as well as Bronze Clay and Copper Clay. In this nontraditional approach to jewelry making you will be making new pieces in no time. With chapters going over all the basics from materials, studio space, equipment, tools and techniques to projects. Professional instruction, step-by-step photos and innovative techniques will inspire you to create gorgeous wearable art of your own. Projects shown below created by artist Mary Hettmansperger.

Stamped Metal Jewelry With Dvd $24.95 Creative techniques and designs for making custom jewelry. Using metal stamps and sterling silver blanks, your jewelry can be personalized with words, textures, and creative designs. Follow along with the 33 minute DVD and develop your metal stamping skills with segments on tools, supplies and stamping basics presented in a clear format with close-up photography. Simple stamped pendant and bonus double sided pendant projects will get you started on fun designs. With the book and DVD, you get the best of both worlds for in-home instruction. With 19 fun and inspiring projects, you will Create charms and incorporate stamped links into your beaded projects Link stamped components with flat wire and wire wrapping Layer, rivet, texture and oxide stamped jewelry components Get step-by-step instructions on 19 projects from the author and guest designers Bloom Pendant made by artist Lisa Niven Kelly. Dessert First Pendant by artist Lori Ramotar. Wisdom Pendant designed by artist Kriss Silva. Take Time to Breathe Pendant made by artist Tracy Stanley.

General Tools General Tools Swivel Head Pin Vise 92 $8.03 Swivel head pin vise For delicate work on models, instruments, and jewelry 2 double end reversible collets made of hardened tool steel Large free wheeling swivel head 4? overall, 5/16? diameter body Capacity: 0 to .125?, .0 to 3.2mm Brand #: General Tools 92 UPC: 038728410627 Keywords: pin vise swivel

General Tools General Tools 18pc Screwdriver Set 63518 $17.53 18pc screwdriver set 18-piece set with interchangeable, extended-shaft blades Includes 17 heat-treated blades: 3/64?, 1/16?, 5/64?, and 3/32? slotted; #000 and #00 Phillips; T6, T7, T8, and T9 Torx; 1/2?, 1/16?, and 5/64? hexagonal; 3/32?, 1/8?, and 5/32? nut-driver; awl/scribe Blade selection reflects most common choices in jewelry and electronics repair Storage case Brand #: General Tools 63518 UPC: 038728634184 Keywords: screwdriver set w storage case precision 18pc

Cooper Tools Cooper Tools 25w Woodburning Tool WSB25HK $13.01 25w woodburning tool Mini iron with pencil handle Ideal for wood burning, hobbies, and crafts Also ideal for jewelry, model railroads, and micro electronics Develops 750 F./400 C temperature Stainless steel barrel and heat and impact-resistant handle Important: Use only Weller tips UL listed Brand #: Cooper Tools WSB25HK UPC: 037103200655 Keywords: woodburning tool

Make It In Minutes Beaded Jewelry $12.95 Make Beautiful Handcrafted Jewelry in Minutes This collection will dazzle bead-happy crafters of every level. All the pieces use easy-to-master methods, including wire wrapping, weaving, crimping, stringing, and stitching, yet theyre positively boutique-worthy. Basics on the techniques, tools, and materials are thoroughly explained in an introductory section, along with advice on choosing bead combinations and arrangements. Project chapters include bracelets, earrings, necklaces, brooches, rings, and watchbands, and within an hour you can create such jeweled treasures as a Hawaiian Haku bracelet, Tropical Sunshine necklaces, Crystal Chandelier earrings, Pearl Marquise ring, and Red With Envy watch. Artist Wendy Remmers studied graphic design at the University of Hawaii and went on to do work for Hawaii and 39;s top public relations agency and Disney before establishing her own business. Always working on crafts, Wendy eventually decided to focus on one of her lifelong hobbies, beading. She is the owner of Brea Beadworks in Southern California. Wendy shares her knowledge through her online newsletter and beading workshops.

General Tools General Tools 4 in Illuminated Magnifier 554 $25.17 4? illuminated magnifier 4? diameter with 3 power lens, covers large areas of print This 4? illuminated magnifier features a powerful 3X lens and a built-in bifocal insert for 5X magnification of extra-fine details Bulb gives wide circle of illumination Switchable light aids inspection in poorly lit areas Plastic body and optical plastic lens Replaceable bulb and 2 ?C? batteries included Great for quality control inspections, jewelry making, and electronics assembly Commonly used in stamp collecting, coin collecting, and model building Focal length of lens is 3-1/3?; bifocal is 2? Brand #: General Tools 554 UPC: 038728424624 Keywords: multi use magnifier mechanics magnifying glass 4? 3x lens hobbies illuminated 3 power bifocal insert

Jewelry Studio Silver Wire Fusing $22.95 Create Dazzling, Handcrafted Silver Jewelry at Your Kitchen Table Artist Liz Jones introduces readers to the new and quickly growing art of Silver Wire Fusing in this simple-to-follow, full color guide. Learn how to make unique, stunning jewelry without the mess and trouble of silversmithing. Using only basic tools and silver wire, you can create beautiful bracelets, necklaces and earrings. This guide will show you how, starting with an overview of tools and materials and several practice exercises. Helpful Good to Know tips are scattered throughout the book, and the gallery is sure to inspire you. Features 22 step-by-step projects, fully illustrated with photographs like the ones shown below. Step-by-Step Silver Wire Fusing images below from book 1. Form rings in silver wire 2. Join and close rings to form a chain. 3. Use a micro torch 6722050 to fuse rings closed. Shape or hammer wire. 4. Tumble project in stainless steel shot 67023, and wear proudly.